Whole Network Most Recent TOP10 Campus Life Career Planning Financial Aid

 

Merit vs. Need in Tennessee (and A Few Other Southern States)

Filed in archive Financial Aid by Greg Cruey on December 16, 2007

Inside Higher Ed has an excellent and detailed analysis of the politics of financial aid and how the tension between need-based aid and merit-based aid is coming to a head in Tennessee.

According to state data for the 2005-06 academic year, Tennessee spends two and a half times as much on merit-based financial aid as it does on need-based financial aid. In Florida the ratio is higher, at three to one. And in Georgia the ratio is much worse for need-based aid.

Race Hall on the campus of the University of Tennessee in Chattanooga


Merit-based aid comes largely in the form of programs like Georgia's Hope Scholarship, funded by state lottery. These types of merit-based programs promise students scholarships to public institutions in their state if they meet certain academic criteria in high school.

The problem is that family prosperity breeds academic merit. Statistically, middle and upper class students do better in high school than students from poor families because the more well off students have a better family suppose system. Poor students often divide their time in much of high school between their studies and a job while students who comes from higher income homes more often avoid that dilemma. The result is that a disproportionate amount of merit-based aid go to students with comparatively smaller financial needs. And in a state like Tennessee, where more than two out of every three aid dollars is awarded based on merit, competition for need-based aid becomes tighter.

I remember the political blood bath in Tennessee over whether or not to have a state lottery. Social conservatives lost and the state lottery has become wildly successful - so successful now that it has more money than it can spend on merit-based scholarships.

Tennessee is now looking at ways to funnel some lottery funds (or at least interest generated by those funds) into need-based aid. And the issue is developing some political heat in the state...


Advertisement


Permalink: Merit vs. Need in Tennessee (and A Few Other Southern States)
Tags: lottery  need  merit  scholarhsips  college  merit+based  merit+need  other+southern 

Trackback: http://www.creative-weblogging.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.pl/106880



Advertisement


Advertisement


CW ToolbarInstall
RSSrss   | See all blog subscribe options
Googlegoogle   |   What is RSS?
Yahoo!yahoo
AddthisAddThis Feed Button
BloglinesBloglines
Newsletter
Advertisement - Book yours here.
universities

Use our search feature to look for other interesting posts

Just this blog Whole network
Advertisement -
Book yours here..


 
Advertisement
Book yours here.



  • Testimonials

  • Thank you for such a clear and concise overview of two publications that I was not aware of before now. I will be sure to pass this information on to the students visiting my site.

    Excellent site, I could really find lots of info for my planned MBA.'
  • Other blogs in the same channel in the Creative Weblogging Network

Advertisement -
Book yours here..






Advertisement - Book yours here..
universities
 
Tagcloud: Academic Freedom Adjunct Instructors Campus Life Campus Security Career Planning College Admissions College and University Profiles College Rankings College Sports College Traditions Community Colleges Courses Courses and Programs Educational Studies Faculty and Scholarship Financial Aid Financing Education Fraternities & Sororities Issues in Higher Education Jobs in Academia MBA programs Miscellaneous Musings Money New Graduates News Philanthropy Professional Education Sponsored Post Student Issues Study Abroad Programs University Administration Writing and Blogging