Whole Network Most Recent TOP10 Campus Life Career Planning Financial Aid

 

Some Students Say: We Don't Want No Education

Filed in archive Issues in Higher Education by Rhys on February 17, 2006

BlogPicture
If you want to know what generation a person is from, just ask them what "PC" stands for.

The young pups will promptly answer, "Personal Computer." For those a little longer in the tooth, the abbreviationlinks will always resonate as "Politically Correct."

During the late eighties and early nineties, the nation was so paralyzed with the fear of offending sensibilities, or of being seen as crude or 'wrong', that many people kept opinions to themselves, or offered banal musings instead of strong thoughts on issues.

There is nothing wrong with being sensitive to others--in fact, empathy is a crucial skill that many students develop during their college years--but there is something wrong with closing your eyes and ears to the world around you.

In a potentially disturbing development, the PC trend is now invading college classrooms.

An Arizona bill is waiting to pass that would allow students to demand alternative coursework if a professor assigns a text or assignment that the student finds "personally offensive." As you can imagine, professors hate the idea of their credibility being questioned. But it's more important to ask: what harm could this do to students?

Inside Higher Ed provides a thought-provoking
article:The Arizona bill goes beyond the measures that have been pushed in other states - in fact it goes so far that David Horowitz, the '60s radical turned conservative activist who has pushed the Academic Bill of Rights, opposes the measure. "It doesn't respect the authority of the professor in the classroom," he said. "This authority does not include the right to indoctrinate students or deny them access to texts with points of view that differ from the professor's. But it does include the right to assign texts that make students feel uncomfortable."

[One professor] said that he respects the right of students to decide which courses to take, but that students can't dictate books to be taught. "This is totally unworkable in the classroom," he said. "If you have students demanding alternative books, and one student is reading one book, and one another, and one another - it doesn't make any sense in terms of how you teach."

And he said that the experience has reinforced for him the value of teaching. "This all was a little difficult at first, with a flurry of e-mails attacking the college and my integrity," he said. "But the more I've learned about academic freedom, the more sure I am that what I'm doing is right and that it matters - to teach students to think critically, to help students come a little bit out of their comfort zones."
As always, issues of this magnitude leave us with more questions than answers.

Which is more dangerous: the possibility of feeling offended, or the possibility of closing yourself off to other views on the world, possibly never changing or growing as a result?

Is college the right place to remain in a bubble? Should students force themselves to consider other ways of life, no matter how unpleasant, or do they have the right to refuse this knowledge? If this legislation passes, what does it hold in store for the future of your higher education years?

Please share your ideas and opinions with us in the Comments section.

(Photo Source: NCSU)



Advertisement




Permalink: Some Students Say: We Don't Want No Education
Tags: college  censorship  students  education  want  some+students  want+education  students+want 

Trackback: http://www.creative-weblogging.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.pl/15696



Advertisement


Advertisement


RSSrss   | See all blog subscribe options
Googlegoogle   |   What is RSS?
Yahoo!yahoo
AddthisAddThis Feed Button
BloglinesBloglines
Newsletter
OnlineUniversities

Use our search feature to look for other interesting posts

Just this blog Whole network
 
  • Advertise with us

  • Learn more about our advertising options or email advertising - at - creative-weblogging.com or give Luis a call at +1 (650) 331 8047.


  • Testimonials

  • Thank you for such a clear and concise overview of two publications that I was not aware of before now. I will be sure to pass this information on to the students visiting my site.

    Excellent site, I could really find lots of info for my planned MBA.'
  • Other blogs in the same channel in the Creative Weblogging Network







OnlineUniversities
 
Tagcloud: Academic Freedom Adjunct Instructors Campus Life Campus Security Career Planning College Admissions College and University Profiles College Rankings College Sports College Traditions Community Colleges Courses Courses and Programs Educational Studies Faculty and Scholarship Financial Aid Financing Education Fraternities & Sororities Issues in Higher Education Jobs in Academia MBA programs Miscellaneous Musings Money New Graduates News Philanthropy Professional Education Sponsored Post Student Issues Study Abroad Programs University Administration Writing and Blogging