Whole Network Most Recent TOP10 Campus Life Career Planning Financial Aid

 

Wall Street Journal B-School Rankings Surprising

Filed in archive by Mark on October 04, 2004

The Wall Street Journal has released its fourth annual ranking of business schools, which results from a survey of corporate recruiters the paper conducts in conjunction with Harris Interactive. This year's winner is Harv...er, Whar...er, Stan...I mean, Michigan. Michigan?

That's right. Michigan took top honors, followed by Carnegie Mellon, Tuck (Dartmouth), Wharton (U of Penn) and the University of Chicago.

According to CareerJournal.com, the paper's executive career site, the rankings now separate schools into three categories---national, regional and international. Here's more:

The new approach retains most of the elements of the original methodology used in the Journal's three previous M.B.A. rankings, including recruiters' perceptions of the schools and students on 20 key attributes, such as leadership potential, teamwork skills and interpersonal qualities, and the school's "mass appeallinks," or the number of recruiters that it attracts. A revised and expanded part of the ranking formula is "supportive behavior," defined as the recruiters' intention to return to a particular school and the likelihood of making job offers to its graduates in the next two years.

What has changed most is the calculation used to arrive at each of the rankings. It was revised to give equal weight to perception, mass appeal and supportive behavior because the old formula resulted in a ranking that was increasingly driven by the mass-appeal factor. In essence, the ranking was becoming more a reflection of the size of the school and its recruiter pool than of recruiters' feelings about the school and its students.
Regardless of methodology, it's interesting to note how far Harvard has dropped. In this poll, HBS ranks 14th. And that's supposed to reflect how recruiters think about Harvard's B-school? I wonder how many students looking at top business schools rank Harvard 14th on their list.


Advertisement




Permalink: Wall Street Journal B-School Rankings Surprising
Tags: Business  college  school  rankings  journal  wall+street  street+journal  school+rankings 

Trackback: http://www.creative-weblogging.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.pl/3449



Advertisement


Advertisement


RSSrss   | See all blog subscribe options
Googlegoogle   |   What is RSS?
Yahoo!yahoo
AddthisAddThis Feed Button
BloglinesBloglines
Newsletter
OnlineUniversities

Use our search feature to look for other interesting posts

Just this blog Whole network
 
  • Advertise with us

  • Learn more about our advertising options or email advertising - at - creative-weblogging.com or give Luis a call at +1 (650) 331 8047.


  • Testimonials

  • Thank you for such a clear and concise overview of two publications that I was not aware of before now. I will be sure to pass this information on to the students visiting my site.

    Excellent site, I could really find lots of info for my planned MBA.'
  • Other blogs in the same channel in the Creative Weblogging Network







OnlineUniversities
 
Tagcloud: Academic Freedom Adjunct Instructors Campus Life Campus Security Career Planning College Admissions College and University Profiles College Rankings College Sports College Traditions Community Colleges Courses Courses and Programs Educational Studies Faculty and Scholarship Financial Aid Financing Education Fraternities & Sororities Issues in Higher Education Jobs in Academia MBA programs Miscellaneous Musings Money New Graduates News Philanthropy Professional Education Sponsored Post Student Issues Study Abroad Programs University Administration Writing and Blogging